Why Is It So Hard to Know What You Want?

You’ve probably had some version of this conversation before:

“What do you want for dinner?”

“I don’t know. What do you want?”

“I’m asking what you want.”

“Whatever you want is fine.”

If that sounds familiar, you know the feeling. Someone asks what you want, you reach for an answer, and nothing is there. It’s not that you’re being polite or difficult. You really don’t know.

Plenty of people assume that means they’re indecisive, or low-maintenance, or just bad at choosing restaurants. Often it’s something else: a skill you never got to practice.

When Your Preferences Never Mattered

Picture growing up in a home where decisions were made for you. Maybe someone asked what you wanted and then did something else anyway. Maybe your preferences got criticized, brushed off, or met with irritation. In some homes, wanting the wrong thing carried a real cost.

After enough of that, you adapt. You stop offering suggestions, because suggestions didn’t change anything. You learn to wait and see what someone else decides, since that’s the version that keeps things calm. Eventually you stop checking what you want at all.

Years later, nobody is stopping you from choosing. You have the freedom. You just haven’t had much practice using it.

Working With Yourself

The Trauma-Informed You explores collaboration, mutuality, and self-knowing as part of renewing the relationship we have with ourselves. Collaboration is simple to describe: two people put possibilities on the table and decide together. You can do that with yourself, too.

Go back to the dinner question. Before you ask what the other person wants, give yourself a few quick prompts:

  • What sounds good right now?

  • What haven’t I had in a while?

  • What would I actually enjoy?

You might still go with their pick, and that’s fine. The difference is that you showed up to the decision with something of your own. You took part in it.

Try It This Week

Pay attention on purpose to how often you reach for an answer from someone else before you’ve looked for your own. Notice what happens when you pause long enough to come up with two or three options just because they interest you, whether it’s dinner, a weekend plan, or what to watch tonight.

It can feel awkward at first, like using a muscle you haven’t touched in years. That’s normal. Knowing what you want involves understanding your own needs, interests, and preferences. The more opportunities you give yourself to consider those things, the more familiar they can become.

Next time someone asks what you want for dinner, you might surprise yourself with an answer.

If You Want Help Going Further

Dinner is a small example, but the same pattern shows up in bigger places: careers, relationships, how you spend your time, what you say yes to. If this one landed, there are two ways to keep going.

The book: The Trauma-Informed You explores how our experiences influence the relationship we have with ourselves and how we can begin renewing that relationship.

The course: Renewing Your Relationship With Yourself is a self-paced training based on the book. It includes video lessons, guided reflections, and interactive workbooks that take you through the Self-Relationship Renewal Model, including collaboration, mutuality, and self-knowing. Enrollment is only $149.

Explore both at renew.indigopathcollective.com.

Jeremy Henderson-Teelucksingh

Dr. Jeremy Henderson-Teelucksingh, DBH, NCC, CCMHC, BC-TMH, is the founder of Indigo Path Collective, an online counseling practice and educational organization dedicated to strengthening relationships, leadership, organizational functioning, and overall well-being through practical, evidence-informed behavioral science. Jeremy provides trauma-informed online counseling for adults in Tennessee, North Carolina, and South Carolina, develops professional training and practical frameworks, and creates books and educational resources that translate complex behavioral science into everyday practice. Jeremy is the author of The Trauma-Informed Manager, creator of Renewing Your Relationship With Yourself: The Trauma-Informed You, and developer of the Human Relations Matrix 2.0 and Values-Aligned Functioning (Values AF). Through counseling, books, professional training, and A Better Us, Indigo Path Collective equips individuals, leaders, and organizations with practical strategies to build healthier relationships, stronger systems, and more meaningful lives.

https://www.indigopathcollective.com/
Next
Next

When Your Behaviors Become A Vicious Cycle