Are You Soothing Yourself or Just Placating Yourself?

You’ve had a terrible day. Work was frustrating, someone said something that stung, and by the time you get home, you’ve had enough. You decide you deserve something nice.

So you order your favorite food, pour a cocktail, and settle in with something entertaining. Maybe you do a little online shopping or scroll until you’re ready for bed. By the time you are ready to fall asleep, you don’t feel as bad as you did when you first got home. But did you soothe yourself, or did you just find a way to stop feeling upset after a no-good, terrible day?

When Feeling Better Becomes the Goal

There’s nothing wrong with a good meal, a favorite show, or a treat after a hard day. These things can be enjoyable, relaxing, and a real part of taking care of yourself.

The trouble starts when they become a way to placate yourself. You’re frustrated, hurt, disappointed, or overwhelmed, and you want those feelings gone. So instead of looking at what you’re experiencing, you reach for whatever will make it stop the fastest. The discomfort may fade for the evening, but whatever caused it may remain unmanaged, so the likelihood of going through the cycle again tomorrow is high.

What Does Self-Soothing Actually Mean?

In The Trauma-Informed You, peer support is one of the trauma-informed principles applied to the relationship you have with yourself. In the Self-Relationship Renewal Model, it corresponds with self-soothing.

Think about how you’d respond to someone you care about who’d had a rough day. You’d probably ask what happened. You’d listen, acknowledge how hard it was, and help them figure out what they need.

Now think about how you respond to yourself. Do you acknowledge what you’re feeling, or tell yourself to get over it? Do you ask what you need, or do you go straight to a distraction like doomscrolling? Would you talk to a friend the way you sometimes talk to yourself?

Self-soothing starts with that kind of attention. Placating skips it and helps you slip into behaviors that avoid the issue altogether.

Self-Soothing vs. Placating: How to Tell the Difference

The activity itself can be identical. A bath, a walk, a movie, or a favorite meal can go either way. What differs is what’s happening underneath:

  • Placating asks: How do I make this feeling stop?
    Soothing asks: What’s going on, and what do I need?

  • Placating avoids the feeling.
    Soothing acknowledges it, even briefly.

  • Placating treats discomfort as a problem to eliminate.
    Soothing considers what that discomfort might be telling you.

  • Placating may provide temporary relief without addressing the underlying concern.
    Soothing creates an opportunity to better understand what you’re experiencing and what you need.

Soothing doesn’t mean sitting in distress for hours or giving up on feeling comfortable. It means you were present for yourself before, during, or alongside the discomfort in an effort to understand what is wrong and how to manage it.

A Simple Way to Start

Next time you’re upset, try these three questions before you reach for anything:

  1. What am I feeling right now? A rough word is fine: angry, embarrassed, worn out.

  2. What do I need? Rest, a conversation, a boundary, a solution, or just to be heard.

  3. What would I say to someone I care about in this situation?

Then go ahead and order the food or put on the show. The difference is that you’ve already checked in with yourself, so the comfort can become part of supporting yourself rather than simply distracting yourself from what happened.

Want to Go Deeper?

If this blog made you stop and think about what and how you are either placating or soothing yourself, there are two ways to keep going.

The Trauma-Informed You is the book behind the Self-Relationship Renewal Model. It explores how our experiences influence the relationship we have with ourselves and how to begin renewing that relationship.

Renewing Your Relationship With Yourself is a self-paced course based on the book, with video lessons, guided reflections, and interactive workbooks that take you through the model, including self-soothing. Enrollment is only $149.

Explore both at renew.indigopathcollective.com.

Jeremy Henderson-Teelucksingh

Dr. Jeremy Henderson-Teelucksingh, DBH, NCC, CCMHC, BC-TMH, is the founder of Indigo Path Collective, an online counseling practice and educational organization dedicated to strengthening relationships, leadership, organizational functioning, and overall well-being through practical, evidence-informed behavioral science. Jeremy provides trauma-informed online counseling for adults in Tennessee, North Carolina, and South Carolina, develops professional training and practical frameworks, and creates books and educational resources that translate complex behavioral science into everyday practice. Jeremy is the author of The Trauma-Informed Manager, creator of Renewing Your Relationship With Yourself: The Trauma-Informed You, and developer of the Human Relations Matrix 2.0 and Values-Aligned Functioning (Values AF). Through counseling, books, professional training, and A Better Us, Indigo Path Collective equips individuals, leaders, and organizations with practical strategies to build healthier relationships, stronger systems, and more meaningful lives.

https://www.indigopathcollective.com/
Next
Next

Why Is It So Hard to Know What You Want?